Wood vs Plastic Toilet Seat

Toilet seats are made of either wood or plastic. Let’s look at why should you buy and why should not buy of these toilet seats but experts don’t recommend changing toilet seats soon after. Because it is not very easy to dispose of the old toilet seats. Choose your favourite toilet seat, in this article i.e wood vs plastic toilet seat you will get full detailed comparison.

However there comes a time when you have to change your old toilet seat as you just can’t clean it. Most of the toilets come without a toilet seat, so you can buy them separately or you can replace them. One of the main contributors in changing the toilet seat is their slamming sound on the bowl as they are present in between our body weight and the toilet bowl. This article will help you in the selection of the best plastic vs wooden toilet seats. I have reviewed all the best toilet seats for your comfort.

Wood vs Plastic toilet seat
Features Of SeatWood Toilet SeatsPlastic Toilet Seats
WeightHeavyLeight
StyleMore elegant and stylish(molded wood toilet seatsLooks cheap and average
CostLittle PriceyBudget-affordable
WarmthRemain WarmthCold in winter season
ComfortComfortable for heavy personsNot  very strong
Legal RequirementsNot used in public bathroomsBest for both public and residential restrooms
CleanDifficult to cleanEasy cleaning

PROS AND CONS OF WOODEN TOILET SEATS

Usually, wooden toilet seats come in two types, the first one is made of solid wood and the second are those made of molded wood. Molded toilet seats are painted in white and they just look like regular plastic toilet seats. While the solid wood toilet seats always retain the color of the wood they are made from. These are also thicker and heavier than molded wooden toilet seats.

Plastic vs Wood toilet seat

Why should buy

  • Have a traditional look.
  • Have weight tolerance.
  • They are warmer.
  • They are more comfortable.

Why should not buy

  • They are not made for public washrooms.
  • Less hygienic.
  • Heavy in weight.
  • Have stability in temperature.

Pros and cons of plastic toilet seats:

As their name suggests, these plastic toilet seats are made of plastic and are accompanied by plastic mounting, or in some cases metallic. Plastic toilet seats are easy to clean as compared to wood.  Its surface can be easily wiped down and you also have an option to use other cleansing materials as the cleansing solutions can damage or stain the wooden toilet seats. Plastic toilet seats have many features that are not found in wooden toilet seats.

Let us have a deep look at the pros and cons of plastic toilet seats.

Why should buy

  • They are durable.
  • They are scratch-resistant.
  • They are very versatile.
  • Powerful flushing
  • Usbale in both public and private toilets.
  • They are more hygienic.
  • They are lightweight.

Why should not buy

  • They are less stylish.
  • They are less sturdy.
  • Easily stained by urine.
  • They are cold.
Toilet Seats 101: All the Info You Never Knew You Needed!

WOOD VS PLASTIC TOILET SEATS COMPARISON

1. Weight Of Toilet Seat

weight at toilet seat

When talking about the weight of both toilet seats, wood always remains at top because wooden toilet seats are heavier than plastic toilet seats. You may be thinking about how the weight of the toilet seats affects the user?
Always remember that both toilet seats are hinged, moving them up and down is as easy as it gets. Imagine a plastic and wooden toilet seat in the open position. Now slam both toilet seats at the toilet bowl. Heavier objects due to gravity affected more than lighter objects.

Wooden toilet seats hit the toilet bowl more harderly than plastic toilet seats. If this happens many times, the wooden toilet seats will break sooner than plastic toilet seats.

Winner: Wooden toilet seats

2. Style

Everything is not beloved as wood. Things made out of wood look stylish, sleek, aesthetically genuine and elegant, as there is no doubt about that. Wood toilet seats are also. I’m talking about solid wood toilet seats, not about the molded toilet seats.
People loving farmhouse themed or rustic bathrooms will also agree with me that wooden toilet seats always standout as compared to plastic toilet seats.
Even though plastic toilet seats also look stylish and elegant, they are harder to compare with wooden toilet seats.

Winner: Plastic toilet seats

3. Toilet Seat Cost

Toilet seats are available at different prices as other things. The cost of the toilet seats not only depend upon the material of the seats but also on many other factors. Some of the features that determines the price of the toilet seats are:

: Mounting type:  Toilet seats are available with top mountings and bottom mounting but toilet seats with top mountings is the best one.

: Warmth: Some toilet seats due to electricity remain warm while some remain cold. 

: Slow-Close Feature: Slow-close feature of toilet seats allows the seat and lid to close softly and slowly without producing the irritating slamming sound.

: Quick-release mechanism: Toilet seats with this feature are designed to easily detach it from the mounting hardware while cleaning the toilet.

: Seats With Nightlight: Toilet seats with nightlights have an LED light that illuminates your toilet and easy bathroom navigation at night.

: Brands: Toilet seats with popular brands are somehow more expensive than usual brands. 

: Wood type: When we talk about wooden toilet seats, the type of wood used to make seats affects its price. As the price of the seats is determined by the material used to make them. From this concept, It is now come to clear that solid wood toilet seats are more expensive than plastic toilet seats.

Winner: Tie

4. Warmth Of Toilet Seat

People using wooden toilet seats enjoy their visits to the bathroom more than the people with plastic toilet seats because wooden toilet seats are bad conductors therefore they will not transfer your body heat to the toilet bowl and you feel warm while using it.

While plastic toilet seats remain as cold as the floor and toilet bowl. The only best way to use a warm toilet seat is to use a heated plastic toilet seat. It will give you a warm feeling and comfort for 24 hours. But this way consumes your electricity.

Winner: Plastic toilet seats

5. Toilet Seat Comfort

Wooden toilet seats are thicker and heavier and therefore are the best option to use for heavy persons. While plastic toilet seats are thinner and are not more strong for heavy weight people, the Big John toilet seat is the best plastic toilet seat for heavy weight people. Modern plastic toilet seats are designed to provide more comfort for their users.

Winner: Wooden toilet seats

6. Legal Requirements

Wooden toilet seats cannot be used in public bathrooms as there is a legal requirement in the United States to have a gap at the front . These  toilet seats are known as open-front or U-shaped toilet seats.

They are meant to allow women to wipe those parts which are sometimes impossible with close front toilet seats. One more advantage of open toilet seats is to prevent the men from staining the seat by urine as this habit may cause infections to other users while sitting on it.

Winner: Plastic toilet seats

7. Versatility

Plastic toilet seats are available in many types but wooden toilet seats are available in only one type apart from the material they are made from. That’s why there are heated plastic toilet seats but heated wooden toilet seats are not available.

Bidet toilet seats are very new plastic toilet seats that are changing the use of bathrooms across the world and are available as electric and non-electric toilet seats. But electric toilet seats are more luxurious than non-electric ones.

Electric bidet toilet seats have many features such as they have a nozzle at the back that washes you after using the toilet with warm water instead of using toilet paper. Some seats dry you after washing with warm air and even some have an air deodorizer to keep your bathroom’s atmosphere clean.

Winner: Plastic toilet seats

8. Cleaning

Toilet seats need to be regularly cleaned as they are some of the most unsanitary objects in your house. However plastic toilet seats are easy to clean as compared to wooden toilet seats. The waterproof varnish on wooden toilet seats are supposed to resist waste and dirt.

Wooden toilet seats often hold unpleasant odors when they are cracked. As the texture of the wood is naturally rougher than plastic leading to more cracks.

Winner: Plastic toilet seats

Our Best Picks Of Wooden VS Plastic Toilet Seats:

Best Wooden Toilet Seats

Best Wood Toilet Seats

1. SANILO WOODEN TOILET SEAT:

This wooden toilet comes in 40 different styles. They are made of molded wood. This toilet is not muchheavy as it is 440 pounds. This is a comfortable toilet seat as it comes with a slow close toilet seat feature. If you need a colorful or rustic wooden toilet then this is going to be best for you. 
Key features: 

  • Shape: round 
  • Dimensions: 17.3 x 14.5 x 2 inches (LxWxH)
  • Slow close soft toilet seat
  • Has strong hinges

2. BEMIS 1500TTT 000 WOODEN TOILET SEAT:

This toilet seat is available as round as well as elongated toilet seats. Installing this seat is not very easy but its system makes sure that the seat will not wiggle at all because it uses Bemis’ Sta-Tite Fastening system. It comes with a one-year warranty. If you do not spend a lot on your toilet seat then this is a great option for you as it is budget-friendly.
Key features: 

  • Shape: oval 
  • Dimensions: 18.63 x 5.88 x 21 inches ((LxWxH))
  • Easy installation
  • Two color matched ring bumpers

3. MAYFAIR 1843SLOW 000 WOODEN TOILET SEAT

This is a soft-close toilet seat and comes in white color. One big advantage of this toilet seat is that it can be adjusted to Kohler, American Standard and Toto. It is also available as round and elongated toilet seats.

This toilet is a part of Bemis manufacturing company that has removed the most common problem of people which is wiggling of toilet seats, by using Bemis’ Sta-Tite Fastening system.

Key features: 

  • Shape: oval 
  • Dimensions: 20.75 x 14.5 x 2.5 inches ((LxWxH))
  • Resists scratching
  • Produces no slamming sound
  • Adjusted to any brand toilet
  • uses Bemis’ Sta-Tite Fastening system

Best Plastic Toilet Seats

plastic toilet seats

1. BEMIS 70 000 Toilet Seat, ROUND, Plastic, White:

This plastic toilet seats fit all the round toilets including Kohler, American Standard, Toto and many more. It is best for residential usage. It is made with solid plastic material which resists stains and fulfills all the legal requirements for the United States.

Key features: 

  • Shape: oval
  • Dimensions: 16.43 x 14.18 x 1.56 inches ((LxWxH))
  • Fits all round toilets.
  • Easy installation
  • Made of solid plastic
  • Fulfills all legal requirements
bemis 70 000 toilet seat
bemis 70 000 toilet seat

2. Kohler K-4775-0 Brevia Toilet Seat

It is made of solid Polypropylene to resist staining and fading. The colour matched hinges of this toilet seat allows you to easily detach it from the toilet bowl for cleaning. It gives a quick attach for a fast and secure installation.

Key features: 

  • Shape: oval, and round
  • Dimensions: 16.63 x 14.19 x 0.75 inches (LxWxH)
  • Fits on one-piece, two-piece, and round front toilets.
  • Comes with colour matched hinges.
  • Due to quick release hinges it is easy to remove for clean.
Kohler K-4775-96 plastic toilet
Kohler K-4775-96 plastic toilet

3. WSSROGY, Round plastic toilet seat:

WSSROGY toilet seat comes with two different installation methods. It is built with a soft-close hinge system which lets you put the lid on without irritating sound. This makes it quite innovative. This plastic toilet seat also comes with a one-year of warranty.

Key features: 

  • Shape: round
  • Dimensions: 16.5 x 14.3 x 2.2 inches (LxWxH)
  • Modern stylish look
  • Has two installation methods
  • Has a soft-close hinge system.
Toilet Seat Round
Toilet Seat Round

Conclusions:

Plastic and wooden toilet seats have their own pros and cons and both are safe to use and are easy to clean. The rule of thumb is to always buy that toilet seat which complements your own taste, your favourite features as given above and your toilet and bathrooms decor.You spent a lot  of time on your toilet seat so be careful while buying it.

Frequantly Asked Questions:

  1. Which is better, wood or plastic toilet seats?

    Wood toilet seats are best for their warmth and strength. However plastic toilet seats are also not bad as they are very good for their elegant design, stain and scratch resistance. Overall both are good, it depends upon your taste and your toilet and bathroom’s decor.

  2. Do wooden toilet seats smell?

    Wooden toilet seats only smell when they are cracked as the urine and water seeps inside the seat and causes bad odor. However a properly finished/brand new wooden toilet seat does not smell.

  3. Are wooden toilet seats sanitary?

    Wood toilet seats are less sanitary than plastic toilet seats as the porous surface often absorbs more liquid than non-porous surfaces. Just be sure to keep the toilet seat clean and free of moisture. However a well polished wooden toilet seat is as sanitary as a plastic toilet seat.

Leave a Comment